indian economy
finance minister

While noting that high interest rates make private capital investment more difficult, Varma said the government is in fiscal consolidation mode, thus reducing the support to the economy from this source. „Because of all these factors, I fear that growth may fall short of what we need to meet the aspirations of our growing workforce given our demographic context and income level,“ he said. Fiscal policy of the country has failed to contain the growing inequality in the distribution of income and wealth throughout the country. Growing trend of tax evasion has made the tax machinery ineffective for the purpose. Growing reliance on indirect taxes has made the tax structure regressive.

India was catapulted as the second fastest economy in the world during his tenure, Tharoor said, adding that India had witnessed a growth rate of 7-9 per cent. Recalling his days as the finance minister, Singh said that he entered the world of politics in the midst of a crisis. On the role of the media in a democracy, the former prime minister said it has a very important contribution to make in the process of nation-building. But while that vision deserves the highest of grades, the substance and the policy actions were not equal to the goal. Fiscal policy also helps in providing stimulus to elevate the savings rate. Led by Adani’s $70 billion pledged investment in green energy infrastructure, India’s tycoons have so far committed to spend far more than the government on the energy transition.

The policy must be used as an instrument for dealing with inflationary or deflationary situations. One way to achieve this is to devise a tax structure, which will automatically counter the economic disturbances as they arise. The second is to make changes in the tax system in order to deal with inflationary or deflationary situations. In countries like India, it is through the direction of the public expenditure rather than taxation that more effective action can be taken to remove the effect of a deflationary spiral. In terms of inflation, anti-inflationary taxes such as excess profit tax and commodity taxes on articles of both general and luxury consumption can be imposed.

As the prime minister in 2004, Singh said, “I took on that responsibility with diligence as my tool, truth as my beacon, and a prayer that I might always do the right thing. As I have said on many occasions, my life and tenure in public office are an open book. There is nothing more that I could ask for.” The former prime minister also said that governments come and governments go, “but this great nation of ours is heir to one of the oldest civilizations known to humanity”. Under the leadership of Prime Minister Narasimha Rao, he said, “we took momentous decisions with respect to our economic policies as well as our foreign policy.

taxation public

This has marred the credit growth in India and thus created hindrance in the greater transmission of monetary policy. RBI not only needs functional independence, but it needs to follow a more pragmatic financial policy. In this scenario, RBI’s role must now be redefined through a recalibrated monetary policy, which is in sync with changing economic conditions.

To increase employment, the state expenditure should be directed towards providing social and economic overheads. The state should undertake local public works of community development involving more labour and less capital per head. The budget is not a mere statement of receipts and revenues of the government. When the budget forms a small part of the national income in developing economies, fiscal policy cannot have the desired impact on the economic development.

Govt to release today India’s economic growth forecast for this fiscal year, weeks ahead of Budget announcements

Fiscal policy means the use of government spending and tax policies to make an effect on monetary matters. If the government isn’t very cautious concerning its expenditure and if there is an overabundance of money supply, this policy could lead to inflation. It expands the expenditure of the government, so it leads to reduced taxation. A reduction in taxes would lead to an increment in the deficit of the government financial plan and this would run towards high borrowing and rising government debt. The main benefit of expansionary fiscal policy is that it works very fast if done accurately.

However, issues pertaining to the incomplete transmission of monetary policy and inherent weakness of inflation targeting approach, are some of the challenges faced by RBI. RBI is the main decision maker for the country’s financial system and is mandated with ensuring its stability. Monetary Policy Framework Agreement 2015 between RBI and the central government mandates RBI to contain Consumer Price Inflation within 4% with a band of (+/-) 2%.

  • The fiscal policy to achieve full employment and to maintain stable price in the economy has been developed in the recent past.
  • Food and some non-food items are provided at a subsidised rate through a chain of Fair Price Shops or Ration Shops.
  • A reduction in taxes would lead to an increment in the deficit of the government financial plan and this would run towards high borrowing and rising government debt.
  • While recent recovery is gratifying, our economy is battle scarred, weak, and needs delicate handling.
  • The following analysis focuses on macroeconomic rather than real sector policies.

Credit growth is already subdued, and would not be impacted by higher rates. The government is unlikely to curb its fiscal deficit in response to higher interest rates. Instead, given global interest rates are at historic lows, raising our interest rates would bring in more ‘carry trades’ of foreign currency inflows chasing higher yields. This would further increase money supply, and, hence, perversely raise the risk of monetary inflation. This underlines a big lacuna in our current monetary policy framework.


“We expect the media to be vigilant, to point out the shortcomings of the government and thus help in improving the effectiveness of governance,” he said in his virtual address at the function. Former Prime Minister Manmohan Singh on Tuesday said media needs to remain vigilant and flag shortcomings of the government with a view to improve the effectiveness of governance. The UK economy will contract even more next year, according to the Office for Budget Responsibility, as the country’s citizens deal with skyrocketing inflation and a cost-of-living problem. The first advance estimates are early forecasts and they usually undergo revisions as more data become available. However, the growth projections will come weeks ahead of the Budget 2023 announcement that is scheduled for February 1.

The above objective can be achieved through proper allocation of resources. We must direct investment in the desirable channels both in the public and private sectors by providing suitable incentives. Productive resources are, within limits capable of being used in various ways, which may accelerate economic growth. The available resources must find their way into the socially necessary lines of development. Non-marketable; that it cannot be sold in the market to the consumer. Our legally-enshrined monetary policy framework requires the MPC to set the policy repo rate, so as to target CPI inflation at 4%.

The central bank will conduct a 14-day variable rate repo auction later on Friday-its first since February 2020-to infuse 500 billion rupees ($6.06 billion) into the banking system. The daily average surplus of 180 billion rupees in the last three weeks is sharply lower than the 860 billion rupees in the first three weeks of 2022. Equity markets globally have turned volatile in the fallout of Silicon Valley Bank and Credit Suisse crises, with some investors adopting a cautious stance that could put further pressure on the markets. Although the situation is getting resolved, the events of the past few weeks have highlighted to companies that they need a professional treasury management function.

Presenting the Jury for The Economic Times Awards for Corporate Excellence

In most of the developed countries like the United States, fiscal policy is agreed upon by the administrative and/or legislative departments. In the U.S., through the federal budget, Congress sets fiscal policy and budgets bills in which the president must then sign into law. He said India liberalised its trade and investment rules to help the country re-integrate with the global economy. “This has contributed to growing impatience and a desire for faster growth and a better quality of life. These aspirations and ambitions are exerting pressures on governments to deliver more, perform better, and be more transparent and efficient,” he added.

What are the problems shortcomings of fiscal policy?

Answer and Explanation: The major problems with fiscal policy are deficit spending, crowding out, timing, political considerations, and effects on international trade. Some government policies to stabilize the economy have long term implications.

Further, Interest rates on small savings remained at elevated levels compared to that of banks. Inflation targeting in India has coincided with a substantial rise in the real policy rate. This has been accompanied by declining borrowing in the formal sector likely affecting investment and thereby growth. However, in the era of globalization, the role of the central bank in the economy must be kept in sync with the changing domestic and global economy. Spending is often wasted and is inefficient, so it is not economically advisable to spend government money in this way.

 The Reserve Bank of India exerts pressure on the Indian banking system without taking any concrete steps to ensure compliance with the rules.  Commercial banks are informed of the RBI’s expectations through monetary policy.  The percentage of NDTL that a bank must keep in safe and liquid assets such as unencumbered government securities, cash, and gold.  SLR changes frequently have an impact on the availability of resources in the banking system for lending to the private sector. However, whenever credit growth recovers, if inflation still persists, the RBI will have to withdraw the punch bowl of banking liquidity rapidly, using the ample tools in its arsenal. Clearly, the current context of an opaque behind-the-scenes integrated framework underneath professed inflation targeting is neither sustainable nor desirable.

What is one of the problems with the implementation of fiscal policy?

Inaccurate Information. Poor information results in fiscal policy sufferings. For example, if a government anticipates a recession, it might want to increase aggregate demand. However, if the prediction is wrong, the economy might grow too rapidly, and trigger an inflation.

Also, the fiscal policy shortcomings Debt Management Agency , proposed in Finance Bill, 2015 should be formed at the earliest to avoid any conflict of interest in RBI’s role in monetary policy formulation and managing government debt. Politicians always use expansionary fiscal policy for other reasons which may not be related to the main purpose. There is one more important thing about expansionary fiscal policy, it restores customers’ and organizations’ confidence. Thus, let’s catch a glimpse at some benefits and drawbacks of expansionary fiscal policy. Corporate tax cuts put more money into organizations’ hands, which the government expectations will be put toward new investments and expanding business. In that manner, tax cuts make employment, yet if the organization already has enough money, it might utilize the cut to repurchase stocks or buy new organizations.

TaxCloud (Direct Tax Software)

Alternatively, the government may also choose to draw upon its foreign exchange reserves or print additional money.  Monetary policy is used to manage unemployment, economic growth, and inflation in the country by the Federal Reserve.  It is vital to influence prices, production, employment, and demand.  The monetary policy is implemented by the Feds through reserve requirements, open market operations, federal funds rate, discount rates, and inflation targeting. Such a relaxation would not normally be a source of concern and might even be warranted.

Even though it is well known, the expansionary policy can include huge expenses and risks including macroeconomic, microeconomic, and political economy cases. The fundamental goal of the expansionary policy is to support total interest to compensate for setbacks in private demand. The expansionary or loose policy is a type of macroeconomic policy that looks to empower monetary development. It is essential for the overall policy prescription of Keynesian financial aspects, to be used during the economic slowdown and recession to direct the drawback of financial cycles. As stating economic slowdown, catch the 3 catastrophic financial crisis. Fiscal policy is a way by which the government attempts to control the economy.


True enough, the next fiscal year saw much of these fickle flows reverse out, causing intense volatility in our currency markets. They still persisted with it, perhaps driven by a somewhat justifiable lack of trust in government. For, any complexity might allow the government of the day to strongly influence monetary policy in support of stimulus and fiscal spending. Second, they likely reckoned that a simple rule-bound framework with the carrot and stick of interest rates can goad the government to pursue appropriate fiscal policies. Fiscal policy such as taxes, tariffs, transfer payments, rebate and subsidies are expected to spur long run economic growth through increased capital formation. Capital formation is considered an important determinant of economic growth.

Pakistan, and international global financial order: Revisiting … – Business Recorder

Pakistan, and international global financial order: Revisiting ….

Posted: Fri, 05 May 2023 01:44:18 GMT [source]

Reliance Industries Ltd.’s Mukesh Ambani and JSW Group’s Sajjan Jindal, along with energy giants like Tata Group, have also rushed to champion the shift to a cleaner future. An official close to the development said that under the revised policy, an employee can accumulate up to 60 days of PLs at the end of a financial year or can encash the same number of PLs. India’s largest stock broker Zerodha’s founder & CEO Nithin Kamath expects the firm’s revenue and profits to expand by one-fifth in the year ended March 31, 2023. But if recessionary trends and market volatility, triggered by geopolitical instability continue, the company’s revenue could fall 40% by the end of FY24, Kamath told ET. Expenditure and can reduce the inflationary impact of such expenditure. Liquidity is also an important factor as these can reinforce or negate the changes in policy rates.

On a broad generalization, excessive printing of money leads to inflation. If the government borrows too much from abroad it leads to a debt crisis. Excessive domestic borrowing by the government may lead to higher real interest rates and the domestic private sector being unable to access funds resulting in the “crowding out” of private investment. So it can be said that the fiscal deficit can be like a double edge sword, which need to be tackled very carefully.

HHS Failed to Screen All Employees Working at Shelters for Migrant … –

HHS Failed to Screen All Employees Working at Shelters for Migrant ….

Posted: Thu, 04 May 2023 19:43:11 GMT [source]

In fact, then as now, domestic credit growth was already muted, and not really adding to money creation. In addition, these reversible flows kept the rupee relatively strong at a time when our current account deficit was a high $49 billion. Besides disadvantaging domestic industry, this also built up our external vulnerability.

Reactions to National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan’s Brookings speech – Brookings Institution

Reactions to National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan’s Brookings speech.

Posted: Tue, 02 May 2023 17:23:42 GMT [source]

Fiscal policy is the set of principles and decisions of a government regarding the level of public expenditure and mode of financing them. It is about the effort of government to influence the economy’s output, employment and prices by altering the level of public expenditure, taxation and public debt. The framework provides no room to even acknowledge these, let alone provide any guidance around policy trade-offs. In the wake of global anthropological shock Covid-19, a sharp slowdown in economic growth and employment prospects is evident in the Indian economy. In this context, Reserve Bank of India’s role in ensuring economic stability, growth and development through effective monetary policy assumes more importance than ever.

Central banks use bank reserve requirements, interest rates, and government bonds that should be held by the banks. There are two types of expansionary policy- Monetary policy and Fiscal policy. The expansionary monetary policy directs on raised money supply, whereas expansionary fiscal policy focuses on increased investment by the government into the economy. First, notwithstanding inflation, short-term rates should continue to stay low, as long as net foreign currency flows continue to pour in, and our credit offtake remains subdued. Withdrawing banking liquidity and raising short-term rates would not impact our depressed credit growth. Instead, it could risk attracting fickle carry-seeking currency inflows, and push up money supply even further.

  • In spite of the growing importance of the public sector in accelerating the process of economic development, the interest of the private sector cannot be neglected.
  • Astute pragmatism will be needed the next year as well, under difficult conditions.
  • We can also achieve this through an increase in public expenditure for promoting welfare to the less privileged class.
  • It is one of the significant ways governments react to withdrawals in the business cycle and deter a financial downturn.
  • The flipside of the expansionary fiscal policy is a contractionary fiscal policy, which includes increasing taxes or diminishing government spending, shifting aggregate demand to the left.

Unlike much of the world, India is grappling with high headline and core inflation, despite a contraction in our income. Lower food prices and higher output should hopefully bring down headline inflation, even as rising money supply and a resilient rural sector hopefully revive economic activity. What if the credit growth were funding productive investments, rather than consumption? Still, a purist might well argue that credit growth is creating fresh money at a time of high inflation, and hence interest rates would still need to be raised. We define money as the sum of currency in circulation and deposits in banks, or ‘M3’ in economic parlance.

What is a major problem with using fiscal policy quizlet?

A problem that makes fiscal policy less effective is that: higher taxes or increased borrowing to fund government spending can reduce aggregate demand.